I have never had the opportunity to look at a lesson from a teacher’s perspective so looking at “Step Up to Writing” was exciting for me. I loved the idea of student involvement and active learning. It was refreshing to see an idea that didn’t involve the teacher commanding the students with a blank piece of binder paper and a pencil without creativity or room for participation. But every great idea has its flaws.
Hillary and I discussed the following:
What do they mean by active reading? Is it beyond comprehension? Because students can read something, understand it, but still not really be active in the learning or classroom lesson. I know I personally have been in a class and known the answer for a math problem but not really known how I got there. The same can happen in writing. The student may understand something and simply write it on their paper just to receive credit because its what they are suppose to do. Teachers must make sure that the lesson reaches everyone. Teachers, therefore, must be active in their teaching.
In terms of summarizing they say that once a student can summarize they are ready for the next level. But many students can summarize and then once recess comes they forget and never remember again. If they can’t hold on to their new knowledge, its a lost lesson. They can’t “put it in their pocket” to use later. So in a way the creativity of the lesson will make it memorable but it must also be valuable and something they will always remember to use.
There are many different approaches to how to teach the lessons, how does this benefit varying types of learners within one classroom? This program is amazing for visual learners. By including picture within the sentences or breaking up sentences to acknowledge the separate parts within create a great visualization of the process involved.
This program encourages mainly group work with an active classroom. However, how does this affect the learning of students who work better independently and may be too shy to speak out in class and participate? It is undeniable that in every classroom there is at least one student, often multiple, who are intimidated when “that” student is always answering. A shy independent learner may feel uncomfortable speaking out and being an active participant in the lesson. As a teacher, we can’t let them fall into the shadows and lose their momentum. They must continue to learn to. There must be a balance between group and independent work because even though a student may work quietly it doesn’t mean that they aren’t actively learning.
Somewhere out there there is an amazing way to teaching literacy to our students. This program has potential, but it all depends on what the teacher does with it and how we interpret it and use it in our classrooms.